First off, a huge thanks to everyone that responded! You are amazing and shared so many details...And shattered every idea I had about heroes!
So, here it goes...It seems my readers prefer their hero to be slightly above average height, not overly muscular (Some even said very lean) , dark hair, and unusually colored or very expressive eyes.
Readers also prefer their hero to not be brooding, but more easy going and fun, somewhat humerous/sarcastic, with a dark past.
That makes me think of a David Tennant sort of guy. What do you think? Do you agree with the survey results? Let me know in the comments!